Weighty issues. Fat lot of good. Other fat-related puns inserted here.
No matter how you find a way to bring it up, it’s been on my mind lately: FAT. There have been many reasons for this. One was the fact that a good friend’s husband made an extremely insensitive (and idiotic considering the fact that she’s gorgeous) comment to his wife regarding her size. But more than that, yesterday, my blog world was crushed a bit when one of my blog crushes, Mysterg, pulled a Debbie Downer on everyone and decided to be FatHaterChampion 2009.
As many of you who have read this blog for a long time know, I’m a fat positivist and health at every size activist. I believe that fat people can be healthy and that fat, in and of itself, is not a bad thing. I believe that diets are wastes of time and only hurt people in the end. And I know that there are facts out there to support me…because studies have proven them to be true. But yesterday, Mysterg decided to pull out the idiot card of all idiot cards–the fat hating card.
See it’s easy to hate fat people. You can call it a condition of our generation. You can call it the side effect of our society. You can damn well do anything you please, but the hard part is to think about the issue critically. Because once you do, you realize it’s harder to lose weight and keep it off than it is to pull down a star from the sky. And once you realize that, you come directly to the conclusion that making fun of someone for a situation that they can’t change, even if they wanted to, is just about as cool as kicking someone’s wheelchair, spitting on someone’s book of faith or beating up someone for the color of their skin or their sexual orientation.
The fact is that once you learn to change your definitions of beauty, your whole world opens up and makes life that much more vibrant and alive. Fat people can be and are beautiful. And if you want to do something that harms beauty, then you my friend are sicker in the head than you once thought.
Would I chose to be fat if I had a choice? Probably not. But I’ve tried my damnest before to lose weight and it just doesn’t hold. I see too many women, in particular, killing themselves trying–doing 30 day shreds or diets that say to eat this or not that or claiming they’re just trying to be healthier when really what they want is to loose pounds. It’s a billion dollar industry that plays off of ideas that fat people are inherently bad and must be stopped. But it’s an industry that is sick and wrong.
The subject of Mysterg’s post, to be fair (though I’d like not to), was whether we should have a fat tax or how we should “solve” the “problem” of “obesity”. (God, I get really quotation mark happy when I get angry!) The fact is that such a tax would hardly do any good. Many of the people that are fat are that way, at least in part, because the availability of cheap good food is shitty whereas the availability of cheap crap food is plentiful. Creating a fat tax only taxes people out of their respective brackets and forces them to eat processed foods, killing them with sodium, carbs and fat not to mention all the unpronounceable preservatives that go along with such things. It’s essentially another way to ghettoize people again along socio economic lines. And it, too, is sick and wrong.
It also ignores the role of genetics, not to mention the increasingly sedentary lifestyle that has become the hallmark of our technological genius as a society. Solve those problems first and then get back to me about wanting to starve myself.
While I know there are people that can lose and have lost weight, the fact is that the vast majority of fat people simply cannot do that for one reason or another. Those of us that are truly fat have gone through the trials and tribulations of being fat knowing full well that if all we had to do was crawl through barbed wire while being lit on fire and asked to solve the mysteries of the universe just to be thin, hell, we’d probably do it. This just isn’t an option.
The fact of the matter is that we’d be a lot better off if we just started loving our bodies the way they are and doing healthy things because they’re healthy–not because we want to change the way we look. I know it’s hard, because I struggle with it every single minute of every single day of my life–and I have been dealing with it for nearly my entire life. There are days when I can’t be positive about being fat, even though it is ever-so-clearly part of who I am. There are days when I can’t be positive about anything. But the fact is that I’m fat and my fat is here to stay–no matter what I do (believe me, I’ve tried). So I can either learn to love myself or I can turn into a self-hating machine.
The truth is that a fat tax, mandatory dietary or exercise programs and the diet industry as a whole won’t prevent people from being fat. It’s been proven. But yet people still try to solve the proverbial problem. And if you haven’t been there, then you don’t really know. That’s the problem with people who try to solve problems that they don’t understand…they end up making assumptions about solutions that they can’t possibly comprehend.
And you know what they say about assumptions…they make a fat ass out of you and me.









Related Articles
View Comments responded in this post
“The fact of the matter is that we’d be a lot better off if we just started loving our bodies the way they are and doing healthy things because they’re healthy–not because we want to change the way we look.”
AMEN!
*stands up and applauds*
Some excellent points here, although needless to say, I don’t agree with them all.
Firstly I should reiterate that I don’t hate all fat people, it’s a particular type of fat person I dislike which I complained about, not because they are fat but rather a.) they complain about being fat but do nothing about it, b.) I don’t enjoy watching these people who are grossly overweight slowly killing themselves.
I agree with you. I don’t believe in crash diets. I do believe we come in all shapes and sizes which are equally as beautiful as each other. I also know that it is perfectly possible to be healthy and fat as it is to be happy and fat.
However…
Can you really argue against something being done to combat obesity and be in favour of fatness? If you forget your personal issues for a moment, forget the instant hurt caused by the word ‘fat’, forget about the aesthetics etc and look at the real issue objectively, I don’t think it is an unreasonable thing to want to encourage people to be healthier and live longer.
It’s not just our generation either. If any of us had a child we would love them unconditionally whatever shape and size they are, but we wouldn’t wish a lifetime of health problems and fatness on them would we? Yet this is the future we face unless we make some sort of stand against obesity.
A fat tax may or may not be the answer. If the money raised by such a tax was used to subsidise cheaper healthy food alternatives and provide better healthcare and therapy for those with eating disorders would that be such a bad thing? Instead of being a way to ghettoize people it would in fact be a way of supporting those who want or need support. It’s just one idea.
P.S. If that is your ass up there it’s hot!
Great post, Kim! I don’t believe that people can chose their body type any more than they can choose their skin color or the way they look. There are always things you can do to improve yourself and your health, but everyone is different and no one should be punished for it. Should we make an ugly tax on all beauty products too?
Great post. I definitely don’t understand the point of a “fat tax.” I think there are much better ways to handle the situation. And you’re absolutely right: we have got to learn to love ourselves however we look! It’s important to be as healthy as we can, but when someone is punished because their genetics or whatever reason makes it harder for them to lose weight…well, that’s just dumb.
For the record, simply from your writing I know you’re a beautiful person, so don’t let pounds tell you any differently!
PS: I laughed so hard at Erin’s comment above me…ugly tax on beauty products! LOL.
Who cares what weight someone is? Who cares if they want to marry their cat? These things will never be my problem…
Love this post, so very well said! This tax on things such as soda has been driving me insane. Look, if people want soda, they’ll still drink it, tax or not. People have with cigarettes for how long? I mean, those making the laws have to be a little more realistic.
I think the most important thing is for someone to be comfortable in his or her own skin. If that means being itty bitty or having some healthy curves, then so be it. People should have the option to live their lives however they see fit. Should they do so through healthy means? Sure, but who am I to tell someone they have to? Who is the goverment to do that?
Well. This was fantastic. Fantastic.
And anyone who thinks starting a post with “You know who I hate? Fat people” is the way to prepare people for reasoned, logical discussion shouldn’t be surprised that the reaction is what it has been.
You are not allowed to hate groups of people for their physical characteristics. The end.
You are awesome… awesome!
I was a skinny skinny little girl, and until I hit high school I was taunted for it. It’s the opposite of fat but it helped me to understand the pain of ridicule.
All of your points are good ones. The only thing remedial I would add is that parents need training in how to prevent their children from becoming fat. Along with the food issues you mentioned, if and when this country ever makes healthy food a priority (unlikely, don’t you think?) people would need to be educated in how to cook good food. Also, I think soft drinks are the worse things ever created. There’s an entire cycle of poverty perpetrated by the damn stuff.
But, all that said, my cat Shiva was fed the same healthy designer cat food that the others in the house eat. She exercised by playing well with her compatriots and with me the first year of her life. She has never had a soft drink in her entire life. And she’s fat. She just is. And we think she’s adorable and amazing and cuddly and yummy…and we tell her so, and she is one happy girl.
This is a fabulous post–I think it is too easy for people to judge someone based on external factors. Unfortunately weight tends to be one of the glaringly obvious ones. Health matters so much more than what any scale says.
I’ve been outraged that hating fat people seems to be an accepted prejudice. Insert any other physical characteristic and the hater would be slammed.
Good job on slamming him.
I couldnt agree with you more and I’m so glad you are defending the defenseless.
I am horribly out of shape, eat mostly food that is terrible for me, and yet am fairly thin. I definitely agree that size has a LOT to do with genetics. I sort of wish the government would tax diet soda, because I halfheartedly hope that will get me to stop drinking it, but I don’t really think it will make much of a difference for me or anyone else. I think modern life requires more willpower than most people have. Even my friend who is a childless, petless stay-at-home girlfriend has a hard time finding time to work out AND eat healthy AND maintain relationships with all her friends.
“The fact of the matter is that we’d be a lot better off if we just started loving our bodies the way they are and doing healthy things because they’re healthy–not because we want to change the way we look.”
A-freaking-men. Being happy with who we are — inside and out — is such an important thing. Because if we don’t love ourselves, life gets tough quick.
Thank you so much for posting this. I needed to read it today.
It’s all very interesting. I was fat. My top weight was 185, my lowest was 108, and I hover around 120 right now. I’m 5’6.5″ tall, and though my mother insisted I was “big boned”, I have a little birdie frame. My wrists are tiny.
I guess what I don’t get is why we are so threatened by what is different about people. I know some folks who carry extra weight that could *probably* drop it fairly quickly if they picked salad more often than they pick cheeseburgers. I also know people who carry extra weight that won’t so much as *LOOK* at a cheeseburger, and yet they get nowhere.
My ex seemed to be instantly angry by the sight of a fat person. He would remark to me and to himself, when we would drive past a heavy girl jogging: “you best keep arunnin’ there!”. I just don’t get that, how seeing a fat person instantly raises someone’s anger level.
Now that I am thin, I get to endure the hate of my chubby coworkers. They tell me to eat donuts, that I need a sandwich, that they didn’t see me because I was standing sideways, that I’m too thin. My doctor says he’d like to see me build more muscle. He refuses to discuss weight, preferring instead to monitor, say, blood sugar, cholesterol, bone density, body fat percentage and general good health. But I am not too thin.
I get tired of people commenting on everything I eat. “If I ate like that, you’d have to grease my ass out the door.” “If you keep eating like that, you’re going to be fat like the rest of us.” That’s when I eat the bad stuff. When I eat the good stuff, then they say “do you have an eating disorder?” “Oh, are we on the salad diet again?”
What the hell is so threatening about someone who is different than you, whether you’re thin and they’re fat or vice versa?
Awesome post, love.
well it is good site and more info and The reason why I got up so early … old pair of your shoes and sign it on the sole with a permanent marker!!
i think there are so many tips!
i think there are so many tips!
Leave A Reply